"The court has finally issued a verdict in The Pirate Bay Trial: GUILTY – as in guilty of “assisting in making copyright content available”. The court issued a 1 year behind bars verdict for all four defendants (Peter Sunde, Fredrik Neij, Gottfrid Svartholm, and dot com millionaire Carl Lundström) and fines totaling 30 million Swedish kroner (more than $3,600,000).
Here is a breakdown of the court’s decision:
Peter “brokep” Sunde: 1 year in prison, $905,000 in damages.
Fredrik “TiAMO” Neij: 1 year in prison, $905,000 in damages.
Gottfrid “Anakata” Svartholm: 1 year in prison, $905,000 in damages.
Carl Lundström: 1 year in prison, $905,000 in damages.
As you can see, all four defendants were treated as a team, which is quite unusual according to Gottfrid Svartholm’s lawyer, Ola Salomonsson. As a team, the four have to divide the 30 million Swedish kroner fine amongst themselves – the amount may seem quit large, but keep in mind that the prosecution, made up of 17 companies (Warner Bros Entertainment, MGM Pictures, Columbia Pictures Industries, 20th Century Fox Films, Sony BMG, Universal, EMI, Blizzard Entertainment, Sierra Entertainment, and Activision, to name but a few), asked for a lot more than that – it asked for 117 million Swedish kroner.
“The trial of the operators of The Pirate Bay was about defending the rights of creators, confirming the illegality of the service and creating a fair environment for legal music services that respects the rights of the creative community. This is good news for everyone, in Sweden and internationally, who is making a living or a business from creative activity, and who needs to know their rights will protected by law,” IFPI (International Federation of the Phonographic Industry) chairman and chief executive John Kennedy said.
Petr Sunde twittered the following: “Stay calm. Nothing will happen to [The Pirate Bay], us personally or file-sharing whatsoever. This is just a theatre for the media.”
The truth of the matter is that this is not the end of the trial; there will be an appeal (both sides have 3 weeks to file an appeal), there will be other court proceedings, and a final decision may still be years away. Still, losing this first round it is not a good sign for broadband development, for torrent sites and for file sharing. Why isn’t it good for broadband development? Consider this: if The Pirate Bay was found guilty of assisting in copyright infringement, then ISPs (internet service providers) can be taken to court over the same charges as well.
Please note that the court’s decision has no bearing on The Pirate Bay site, only on the 3 co-founders (Peter Sunde, Fredrik Neij, Gottfrid Svartholm) and the dot com millionaire that supported the torrent tracker (Carl Lundström). The Pirate Bay site will go on, Peter Sunde declared. "
Petr Sunde twittered the following: “Stay calm. Nothing will happen to [The Pirate Bay], us personally or file-sharing whatsoever. This is just a theatre for the media.”
The truth of the matter is that this is not the end of the trial; there will be an appeal (both sides have 3 weeks to file an appeal), there will be other court proceedings, and a final decision may still be years away. Still, losing this first round it is not a good sign for broadband development, for torrent sites and for file sharing. Why isn’t it good for broadband development? Consider this: if The Pirate Bay was found guilty of assisting in copyright infringement, then ISPs (internet service providers) can be taken to court over the same charges as well.
Please note that the court’s decision has no bearing on The Pirate Bay site, only on the 3 co-founders (Peter Sunde, Fredrik Neij, Gottfrid Svartholm) and the dot com millionaire that supported the torrent tracker (Carl Lundström). The Pirate Bay site will go on, Peter Sunde declared. "
I read through enormous comments and feedbacks in forum. Well, the point here is that the judgement above is gonna hold, that would possibly an end to file sharing sites, file sharing softwares, torrents, limewire, bearshare, mp3rocket, morpheus, etc. etc. Looks like big problem for the millions of people out there who have been used to these stuff. On the other hand, it would be considered a big win for those copyright holders and software companies who have been striving to come up with good software (some a bit too expensive though. ;) ), only to find out their software can now be downloaded in some file sharing portal. That would also mean that ISPs and search engine companies would have to change their internal algorithms in order to remove these sites and to detect/prevent other sites from getting into their engine's search index, less they would also be hold accountable for the zillions of legal software only out for free grabs.
I heard the trial is still a long reach from finality, as there would definitely be appeals and more hearings to come, I'll try to get some more developments on this one....